In my life,
I have had little experience with the Quran or Islam in general. Having grown
up as a Christian, not much thought was really ever given to their beliefs. The
only other time that I have learned about it was in a high school history
class, and the teacher had us all read a passage and guess what it was from. It
was some story that is also in the Bible, but I can’t remember which. Everyone
in the class thought that it was from the Bible, but the teacher revealed to us
that it was, in fact, from the Quran. Even as I read the passage, I thought
that it was some strange translation of the Bible or something, as it sounded
very much like it and contained a shared story. Until now, that was really one
of my only experiences with the Quran, and all I remember is that it seemed
very similar in at least the part that we read.
In this
reading, one thing that stuck out to me throughout was how God is referred to
and described. In the fifty seventh Surah, it says that “He is the dominion
over the heavens and the earth…has the power to will anything…and has full
knowledge of everything”. This is very similar to the way that we view God as
Christians: all-knowing and powerful. We believe that there is one God above
all else, which is also how the Quran describes God. Also, as Christians, we
believe and depend on God’s grace and compassion, which is also a trait given
to God in the Quran. God is called “the dispenser of grace” and compassionate
in the fifty seventh Surah. This quality is one that I would consider central
to Christianity, and it is interesting to see that it is also a defining characteristic
of God in Islam as well. It’s surprising how similar the core beliefs about God
are between Christianity and Islam, and I think that most people would not
expect how comparable these things are.
Another
similarity that I found was that of how the concepts of heaven and hell are
described. In the Quran, the separation of grace and mercy from suffering
defines eternity. Those who did not pursue God will spend eternity separated
from his mercy. This is similar to the belief that we hold as Christians as
well, as those that do not follow God will be eternally divided from him. I
thought that this was very unanticipated as well, and that Islam and
Christianity both define eternity in a very similar way. The separation from
God is what lies before those do not follow him in both religions.
While I do
not have very much experience with the Quran in general, it is always
astounding how similar it is to the Bible. The way that it defines God’s
characteristics continues to remind me of it. Also, this time reading it I got
to see how similarly it refers to eternity, and I found that equally
surprising. While there are very clear differences, I am always intrigued by
how similar some of the values are.
Score: 46/50. Fist, I took of one point for a few minor grammar issues. Then, I took off two points because I would have liked to have a seen a little more analysis of what you thought about different parts of the Quran. You very briefly state how the Quran is similar to the Bible in various ways; however, I feel you could have gone into a bit more detail. The other point I took off was because while you compare it to Christianity in general, you don't connect it to specific parts of the Bible which could have reinforced your argument. Overall, this is good.
ReplyDeleteEthan,
ReplyDeleteI thought you did a good job with this week's essay! There are some things that can be improved upon, but overall, great job.
46/50
Depth: 18/20
I took off two points from depth because while I felt you read and understood the text, I would have liked you to dig a little deeper into the text. At points, your blog seemed more like a summary of the similarities between Islam and Christianity, and I would have liked you to incorporate more of your own thoughts and opinions.
Scholarship: 18/20
I deducted two points from scholarship first because of the lack of outside sources. I think outside sources could have strengthened your point and made this overall a stronger paper. You mentioned similarities between Islam and the Bible; however, you gave no specific reference for the biblical beliefs you mentioned. Also while your points demonstrated understanding of this text, they were not exactly thought-provoking or critical.
Polish: 10/10
This was a well-written essay with very few grammar errors. It was clean, easy to read, and concise.
Overall, great job!