The ideas
of ignorance, intelligence, and truth are values that span nearly every
culture, religion, and philosophy. The struggle to obtain absolute truth and to
eradicate blindness is one that many would view as very important, but they
would also disagree on how to go about this. In The Republic and Timaeus,
Plato’s thoughts on these subjects were discussed, and there were some very
obvious similarities to both the Christian faith and previous readings that we
have done.
Starting
with the metaphor of the cave in book 7 of The
Republic, Socrates shows how education and thinking bring about the rise in
understanding. The ascension of the people in the cave into the outside world
was characterized by the acquisition of a deeper comprehension of the world,
and the steps to reaching this involve changing one’s entire way of life. Both
pieces essentially compare ignorance to living in darkness, and it is alike to
not even being able to think for ourselves. Stepping out of the cave is gaining
knowledge and reasoning for yourself, allowing one to have their own beliefs
and ideas. This relates, in a way, to Christianity as well. The world is
constantly searching for a source of truth to cling to, and they never find it
in worldly things. As Christians, we find our truth and beliefs based in the
Lord, and we are able to be absolutely certain about what to believe. In a way,
this allows us to “step out of the cave” and to have a greater understanding
that we know is grounded in truth.
The texts
also talked about the importance of education in the world. As the people left
the cave, their increase in knowledge symbolized the effects of education. Learning
led the people to higher philosophical position which is similar to how Holmes
discussed education in The Liberal Arts.
In this, Holmes explained how education not only is important in our lives but
can actually teach us more about God. This is very similar to how the people
that leave the cave and gain knowledge reach a higher state, almost as if they
are getting closer to God.
Another
thing that I found interesting is how Socrates believed that only certain people
should be involved in higher thinking and bringing other people out of the
cave. I definitely agree that we need to bring people “out of the cave” and
show them the truth, but I don’t really think that it should be exclusive. This
is just like how, as Christians, we need to bring others to know God. It is our job, as anyone that has “stepped
out of the cave” and knows God, to reach others to be saved also.
47/50 I thought that you did a great job of including several points from each source, and I thought your connection to both the Holmes reading and the Christian faith showed a wide range of thinking. I took off 2 point for depth because although you talked about several points, I think that there could have been a little more analysis of the text. I took another point off of depth because your post was under 500 words. Other than that, I think it was a great post.
ReplyDelete